As other reviews mentioned, following directions perfectly, they don't fit into the frame. I had to smash them to fit. There were also a handful of mistakes in the book. The first mistake I pointed out to the store but never got a response - VERY poor customer care. After spending well over $100, I would expect better. The beige color comes out dark brown and ugly; I even reordered beige hoping for a different batch but it was the same and I didn't use it. Further, I had to reorder sage green 1/8 to have enough to finish. I found the designs very hard on small motor corrdination, even though I've done years of quilling. Granted I'm pretty old. However, they are beautiful and brilliantly designed. I got the tree from Michael's and it looks like one pictured at the end of the book. In all, can't say a 5 but if you put up with all the other annoyances, it's probably a high 3 or low 4. Ornaments are beautiful.